Rated 3 out of 5Â by jennienfer not sure about this material
i was really excited about this skirt, but it's times like these i really wish there was a physical anthro store in my city, because there are plenty of things that photos can't convey. the skirt looks like it would be very structured, with maybe a little spandex for movement like the listing indicates, but it is sooo loose and stretchy due to the fabric. the waistband is elastic and a very structured knit, which is great--it will hold its shape. unfortunately, the lining is a looser, ribbed knit, which 1) will lose its shape over time, as ribbed knits almost always do, and 2) doesn't fit as tight as i would personally like. the same goes for the sheer outer layer, which is a pleated fabric, and the pleats aren't sewn or fixed down in any way. although it looks nice now, i'm concerned that the outer layer may lose its pleating and thus its shape over time. as for the fit, i am a solid medium with curvy hips (28" waist, 39" hips), and while i sometimes have to size up on bottoms, i am seriously considering exchanging this for a small (or returning it altogether)--but again, i like my skirts to fit tight, and due to the fabric, especially the lining, that's not happening with this in a medium. if you like a looser fit, go with your usual size. i do love the versatility of this not-so-basic black skirt, and the look of the shorter lining vs the longer, sheer layer, so i'm torn over keeping it or not...
March 10, 2013
Rated 1 out of 5Â by MissUmaple It's strange
I loved the fabric and the quality of this skirt. Very well made! The fabric is very stretchy and soft. I thought the length was rather strange. I'm 5.9" and it pretty much hit me like it's shown on the pictures. So it's not maxi, not mid-calf. Somewhere in between. Also, this is not made for curves. Because it's cut straight and the fabric is stretchy, it hugged every curve of my hips down to about half way to the knees and then just dropped straight down skimming the legs. Wasn't flattering or looked pretty. Probably would look a lot better on slender girls.
February 13, 2013
Rated 5 out of 5Â by clinton08 Cuter than pictured
Tried this on in store and was surprised to find how flattering it is. I thought it might look odd, but the black column is quite slimming. And I actually like the sheer bit at the bottom, because it keeps it from being matronly. I appreciate the pull-on styling. Seems to run true to size. I'm a size 14/16 and the Large fit fine with spanx, gave it a nice, close fit.
January 29, 2013